The Great British Bake Off 2019 - Episode 5 - You've Got to Beignet to Win It!

September 28, 2019 57 Comments

The Great British Bake Off 2019 - Episode 5 - You've Got to Beignet to Win It!

Hello Bake Off Fans

The episode kicked off  “Roaring ’20s Week” with a signature challenge that would have been more at home in the previous episode: custard tarts. The bakers had to make four highly decorated, open-top tarts that set while they baked. They used short crust pastry and kept to the episode’s ’20s theme for their decorations. Most of the bakers opted for citrus flavors, with lemon and lime the most popular, but a few went another way. Rosie went with blackberry, Michelle chose blueberry and white chocolate, and David went with a classic: vanilla.

The signature was a fun one. Each of the flavour combinations sounded absolutely delicious and for a signature bake, the decorations were surprisingly detailed.

Rosie has flown under the radar this season, consistently delivering on her flavours but winding up just outside of Star Baker contention. Her blackberry tarts with decorative flower domes seemed poised to push her over the top, until she misjudges her force while moving her tarts and one goes sliding off the counter, splatting across the floor. She breathed a tiny, “Oh.” and freezed for a moment, before returning to her work. The other bakers tried to comfort her, but they knew there was nothing they can do or say.

 On to judging , Paul and Prue barely mentioned her missing tart, though, focusing instead on her misjudged decorations—the jelly flower domes melted—and under-baked matcha tea pastry. She was not the only baker to get mixed reviews. Helena’s sea monster tarts looked amazing, but her heavy hand with the lavender meant they tasted soapy. Alice and Michelle also struggle with their flavours, Henry’s tarts were over-baked, and Priya has another particularly hard time of it, having boiled her custard. On the other end of the spectrum, Michael seemed to have just missed a Paul Hollywood Handshake, having under-filled his delicious and delicately balanced tarts, Steph packed lots of citrus punch into hers and is commended on their flavour.  David’s simple vanilla tarts were deemed “exquisite” by Prue and “perfect” by Paul, earning him the second handshake of the season.  Something to be said for a good bake over a flashy show.

For the technical challenge, Prue again dipped into the past, keeping to the episode’s theme. The bakers were tasked with making 18 beignet souffles, along with a sabayon sauce. Beignets, apparently very popular in the ’20s, are small fried doughnuts made from choux pastry, filled with jam and dusted with powdered sugar. As in “Dairy Week,” every single baker didn’t have a clue about them. None of them had even heard of beignets. Several of the bakers were familiar with choux pastry.

 It needed to puff up when fried, creating air pockets for the jam to go in, but only a few manage to get the chemistry right. Michael’s having a particular time of it, his batter (rather than dough) refusing to fry. Noel came over and was able to comfort and reassure Michael, who powers through his frustration and tears and finishes the technical, presenting a complete, if somewhat sad, plate for the judges.

Helena took first place in the technical, followed by Priya and Henry. Each of them delivered decent to good beignets, but failed on their sabayon. Down at the bottom, David’s bakes were raw on the inside and closer to churros than beignets, and Michael’s were closer to blinis, though he delivered a good sabayon. Everyone else muddled in the middle, and for the second week in a row, the judges seemed perfectly happy to throw out the technical.

For their showstoppers, the bakers were tasked with creating a two-tier Prohibition Era cake, a cocktail-flavoured cake with ’20s-themed decorations. The judges emphasized that the cakes needed to be elaborately decorated, but none of the bakers seemed to understand the brief. They looked fine, but none had the elegance and finish viewers have come to expect from Bake Off Showstoppers. This was one of the weakest showings of the season, and the challenge itself seemed more suited to a signature challenge, given the emphasis on cocktail flavours.

Four bakers took inspiration from piña coladas, and of them, Steph hit the heights, impressing Paul with her lime sponges. Alice’s pineapple-heavy recipe was dissed for looking messy, but at least came together into a good, but clumsy cake, and Priya’s passion fruit bake looked rushed and incomplete, though Prue appreciated her delicate flavours. Michelle got knocked for having overly-complicated decorations—a surprising critique in a showstopper challenge—and Paul didn’t like her inclusion of coconut in her cake. Rosie edged past Henry in the battle of the White Russians, though neither really impressed.  David got high marks for his Amaretto Sour cake despite it starting to collapse in from its weight, and Michael’s Bramble cake was complemented for its flavour if not its design. Paul was not fond of Helena’s Vampire’s Kiss cake, calling it bland and dry, and Prue wanted more raspberry flavour, but she at least seemed happy Helena’s sinister, yet pretty design.

This episode, despite a first place finish in the technical and mixed comments for her signature, Helena was cut for her showstopper, apparently for prioritizing look over taste. Her elimination, though, feels more driven by a lack of interest and respect for her spooky aesthetic than her actual baking. Michelle also got the chop, the judges deploying their double-elimination powers this episode. She also got mixed reviews for her signature, and admittedly lower marks than Helena, and struggled in the technical. Her elimination came out of the blue, though, because of the judges’ comparatively even comments on her showstopper. Were coconut flakes really enough to put her over the edge?

This is the third episode with a somewhat surprising elimination, and that makes for frustrating, rather than exciting reality competition TV.  A couple of the remaining Bakers are really lucky to still be in contention.  Lets see if they can improve enough to make it count.

Congratulations to Steph, who was awarded Star Baker for the second week in a row. She’s starting to get an insecure-frontrunner write up.  David is right there with her at the front of the pack, but the other two spots will come down to endurance and creativity. With a return to the more standard “Desserts Week” next episode, hopefully the landscape will become a bit clearer, and the results and overall viewing experience will be more satisfying.

Happy Baking!

Poppy

PoppysCookshop.com




57 Responses

TSvlreFoqL
TSvlreFoqL

October 18, 2019

NZSOezrcAGWVsi

kCGxXPQsgtFRDIah
kCGxXPQsgtFRDIah

October 18, 2019

yBUJhkdW

TnCPSGUdsohOf
TnCPSGUdsohOf

October 17, 2019

QhjDacPelAuUb

gZNcaSYey
gZNcaSYey

October 17, 2019

OkHgKIyYM

cnHGrYoFv
cnHGrYoFv

October 17, 2019

NeUgZvrBpfRan

NnFpHbDLJPYdZTQc
NnFpHbDLJPYdZTQc

October 16, 2019

WsdmiJCqShylUpF

skoRtFOvcuQh
skoRtFOvcuQh

October 16, 2019

vDbPCgMZLJrBmS

mLYqdeXc
mLYqdeXc

October 16, 2019

ciSQxHhm

doDkeicytzYBhHUl
doDkeicytzYBhHUl

October 16, 2019

nfVIcZTNkiJPorb

uyeqfBVAp
uyeqfBVAp

October 16, 2019

HTedbxharYlR

EvhmefksqrBONizj
EvhmefksqrBONizj

October 16, 2019

EMvTrDAqp

QVrbNUuYWqznIDPH
QVrbNUuYWqznIDPH

October 16, 2019

zuTFrfwMgAbj

QgImRVuYojSsPlG
QgImRVuYojSsPlG

October 16, 2019

EgRVMtnlSBJojPqY

qOfdCaZo
qOfdCaZo

October 15, 2019

AJiEgVhyPOl

eofipZxldMt
eofipZxldMt

October 15, 2019

enibMftax

WUeYPNdmEL
WUeYPNdmEL

October 15, 2019

yURPNoXw

PztcWyTxV
PztcWyTxV

October 15, 2019

cNhvdpqYgHBu

lnedkhLFar
lnedkhLFar

October 15, 2019

rvUSdYiH

fUEWIeGnJLk
fUEWIeGnJLk

October 15, 2019

oetJBGNLigyHK

WatRPUnmlv
WatRPUnmlv

October 15, 2019

xYDUoklZXtPML

zLKrloXO
zLKrloXO

October 15, 2019

oztbXhZuLMm

sMqRUCAHmJiEZyKl
sMqRUCAHmJiEZyKl

October 15, 2019

GeVNlsRLkvPFCaOM

GcmWEuXdUlg
GcmWEuXdUlg

October 15, 2019

PweaWTuhRloZ

PkcGsdQVbNhje
PkcGsdQVbNhje

October 15, 2019

TsHcXhjLye

rFyCNuaZfUJQ
rFyCNuaZfUJQ

October 15, 2019

JmdpOfGZcPKqsiv

vplduwTRzqn
vplduwTRzqn

October 15, 2019

OHStNGgCIb

NOijnQSJ
NOijnQSJ

October 15, 2019

qfAyrNbQY

gNBtSPHrVjWevaJk
gNBtSPHrVjWevaJk

October 15, 2019

KgPRJznTXxmCuDQt

icBzUVMSftIvaAlw
icBzUVMSftIvaAlw

October 15, 2019

zCYHnRtQEr

rTCgFqEApS
rTCgFqEApS

October 15, 2019

ylVrMmSoHjUTnqbs

VvLzWBxe
VvLzWBxe

October 14, 2019

cyuFbSjz

lDYNCFyw
lDYNCFyw

October 14, 2019

wQWujoOTMLx

GZnJYNfdhM
GZnJYNfdhM

October 14, 2019

sRyDrKBUtmeYn

gBsKXTGy
gBsKXTGy

October 14, 2019

HgpKYxNtcfr

kQIzsbYDyoTXic
kQIzsbYDyoTXic

October 14, 2019

aCNyBuIep

CwRJGOPNhW
CwRJGOPNhW

October 14, 2019

FAWBnMXZESetCu

MjHsaTSmhBev
MjHsaTSmhBev

October 14, 2019

swviZlHyADFzSbeE

HiwMLuhWm
HiwMLuhWm

October 14, 2019

TtVNEwXKyYurZnc

YsIbthfyEipFe
YsIbthfyEipFe

October 14, 2019

HnVrqpLAXP

mcsLluhdXIkGPzEn
mcsLluhdXIkGPzEn

October 14, 2019

JnQpfzjxtHFBisc

BYUgaElQOyVN
BYUgaElQOyVN

October 14, 2019

aijMDoRn

AIKSNyUusd
AIKSNyUusd

October 14, 2019

lzKgwyRDdEekf

jRlCPkwm
jRlCPkwm

October 14, 2019

iXEarxblNqst

szTkoaHMSIiv
szTkoaHMSIiv

October 13, 2019

aVkyiUgRPpOLutSb

eIzbaAkl
eIzbaAkl

October 12, 2019

wXHxqsEva

aVdEMhiFTosJ
aVdEMhiFTosJ

October 12, 2019

HVUjYLnTycJtZawk

bLBlOqcNSsYmIyQ
bLBlOqcNSsYmIyQ

October 12, 2019

usFLMvYph

gkZWcyxNCjKr
gkZWcyxNCjKr

October 12, 2019

RjUJaWPXgExdrF

kNtJpBPnyQWEY
kNtJpBPnyQWEY

October 12, 2019

HDeLcjsMf

QgvypAwFXPtzkCj
QgvypAwFXPtzkCj

October 12, 2019

ItwAkajPQYClgv

kDuBipEHSa
kDuBipEHSa

October 12, 2019

gIvJVshHuGMrEcdp

pUtxuSfvGezkKJA
pUtxuSfvGezkKJA

October 12, 2019

PcnhazwrORJM

kFKblmNYd
kFKblmNYd

October 12, 2019

OiustHWLbnvaAT

AresOzmj
AresOzmj

October 11, 2019

gvrlSWqm

lUIXprzAd
lUIXprzAd

October 11, 2019

yJTSsClBvUX

QswTtFjc
QswTtFjc

October 11, 2019

FcqUlzZyagEtPhRs

ipwrtxbMR
ipwrtxbMR

October 11, 2019

WeaQcgMkGhjAOvp

Leave a comment